I want to withdraw a cheque bounce complaint I filed about two years ago after reaching an understanding with the accused. Given this situation, I want to know: Can compounding fees or costs be imposed by the court while allowing settlement at a later stage?
When parties to a cheque bounce case settle late, perhaps after years of trial or during an appeal, they are often surprised when the court, while happily recording their settlement, directs the accused to pay an additional sum as โcostsโ to the Legal Services Authority. The accused may protest: โWe have settled; the complainant is satisfied; why must I pay more?โ Let me explain clearly. Compounding costs imposed by the court at later stages are a well-established feature of cheque bounce law. The Supreme Court, in Damodar S. Prabhu v. Sayed Babalal H. (2010), laid down guidelines under which courts allowing compounding at later stages impose graded costs as a condition, while retaining discretion to reduce them in appropriate cases.
Let me begin with the problem the Supreme Court was addressing. Section 147 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, inserted in 2002, makes every offence under the Act compoundable at any stage, notwithstanding anything in the Code of Criminal Procedure. But the statute does not lay down any procedure for compounding or any consequences for delay. The Supreme Court observed in Damodar S. Prabhu that accused persons were frequently prolonging cheque cases through trial, appeal and revision, and then compounding at the last stage, after consuming the time of courts at every level. Cheque cases formed a very large share of pending criminal cases, and this practice was adding to the backlog.
To address this, the Supreme Court, invoking its power under Article 142 of the Constitution of India to do complete justice and recognising a legislative vacuum regarding the procedure for compounding, laid down guidelines. Under Article 141, the law declared by the Supreme Court is binding on all courts in India, and these guidelines have been consistently followed by trial courts, appellate courts and High Courts ever since.
The guidelines are as follows. First, the summons issued to the accused should state that the accused can apply for compounding at the first or second hearing, and if they do so, compounding may be allowed without any costs. Second, if the accused applies for compounding at a subsequent stage before the Magistrate, compounding may be allowed on condition that the accused pays ten percent of the cheque amount as costs, to be deposited with the Legal Services Authority or such authority as the court deems fit. Third, if compounding is sought before the Sessions Court or a High Court in revision or appeal, it may be allowed on condition that the accused pays fifteen percent of the cheque amount by way of costs. Fourth, if compounding is sought before the Supreme Court, the figure increases to twenty percent of the cheque amount.
The guidelines also provide that the competent court may reduce the costs with regard to the specific facts and circumstances of a case, while recording reasons in writing. And they require complainants to disclose whether they have filed other complaints in respect of the same transaction, to prevent multiplicity of proceedings, with the Court indicating that where an accused faces multiple complaints arising from the same transaction, costs should not be imposed in a way that multiplies the burden unfairly.
So the answer to whether the court can impose costs while allowing compounding at a later stage is clearly yes. The costs are not a penalty for the offence, which ends on compounding, but a condition for allowing compounding after the accused has consumed judicial time. They are payable to the Legal Services Authority, which uses such funds for legal aid, not to the complainant. And they are calculated on the cheque amount, not on the settlement amount.
Because compounding costs can be substantial and the court has discretion to reduce them, presenting the right material can make a real difference. The settlement-cost advisers at Aapka Legal Advice can help you prepare an application for reduction of costs where appropriate. For representation in compounding at any stage, the Top Cheque Bounce Lawyers in India | Aapka Legal Advice appear before trial courts, appellate courts and High Courts. Where large cheque amounts make the costs significant, our criminal lawyers can also consult a panel of retired judges, including former High Court Justices and retired Sessions Judges, on the strongest grounds for reduction.
Let me now explain when courts reduce or waive costs. The guidelines expressly allow reduction with reasons. Courts have reduced or waived costs in a variety of situations. These include cases where the delay was not attributable to the accused, for example where the complainant sought repeated adjournments or the court itself was unable to proceed; cases where the accused is in genuine financial hardship and has stretched to pay the complainant; cases where the parties made earnest attempts to settle earlier, for example through mediation, but did not succeed until later; and cases where the cheque amount is very large, so that a percentage-based cost would be disproportionate. The Supreme Court itself, when compounding cases before it, has sometimes reduced the twenty percent figure in view of the facts.
The accused should file a specific application seeking reduction or waiver, with supporting material. Simply asking orally at the compounding hearing may not be enough. The court must record reasons whether it grants or refuses the reduction, which provides a basis for challenge if the decision is unreasonable.
What happens if the accused does not pay the costs? The guidelines make the payment of costs a condition for allowing compounding. If the accused does not pay, the court may decline to record the compounding, and the case may continue. In practice, courts often record the settlement and direct payment of costs within a specified time, passing the final compounding order on proof of payment. The accused should therefore budget for the costs when negotiating the settlement.
Can the complainant waive the costs? No. The costs are payable to the Legal Services Authority, not to the complainant, so the complainant has no power to waive them. Only the court can reduce or waive them under the guidelines. Parties sometimes agree in their settlement who will bear the costs, but that is a private arrangement; the court will impose the costs on the accused as a condition of compounding.
What about closure without the complainantโs consent? In Meters and Instruments Pvt. Ltd. v. Kanchan Mehta (2017), the Supreme Court held that where the accused pays the cheque amount with reasonable interest and costs, the court may close the proceedings in the interests of justice even without the complainantโs consent. The reference to โcostsโ in that context includes costs that the court considers appropriate, which may include costs in the spirit of Damodar S. Prabhu. In Raj Reddy Kallem v. State of Haryana (2024), the Supreme Court, in closing a case under Article 142 despite the complainantโs refusal to compound, also considered the amounts paid and costs.
What about settlements through Lok Adalats and mediation? When a case is settled before a Lok Adalat or through court-annexed mediation, the question of Damodar S. Prabhu costs may arise when the settlement is placed before the court for compounding. Practice varies. Some courts insist on the costs according to the stage; others reduce or waive them, recognising that the parties cooperated in an alternative dispute resolution process. Parties should ask the court specifically to consider reduction in such cases.
Let me now place these costs in the context of the overall financial picture. Compounding costs are only part of what late settlement costs the accused. Delay also increases interest, which in R. Vijayan v. Baby (2012) the Supreme Court indicated may reasonably be calculated at nine percent simple interest per annum on the cheque amount. Delay may lead to interim compensation of up to twenty percent under Section 143A, which the Supreme Court in Rakesh Ranjan Shrivastava v. State of Jharkhand (2024) held is discretionary; to an appellate deposit of at least twenty percent of the fine or compensation under Section 148, ordinarily required as held in Surinder Singh Deswal v. Virender Gandhi (2019); and to higher legal fees. The cheapest option of all remains payment within fifteen days of the legal notice under clause (c) of the proviso to Section 138, which prevents any offence from arising.
Let me now explain the wider procedure. The cheque must be presented within three months of its date under clause (a) of the proviso to Section 138. The payee must send a written notice within thirty days of receiving information of dishonour under clause (b), and the drawer has fifteen days to pay under clause (c). If the drawer does not pay, the complaint must be filed within one month under Section 142(1)(b), before the Magistrate where the payeeโs bank branch is situated, under Section 142(2). Under Section 223 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), the accused is heard before cognizance, and bail is a right under Section 478. The trial is summary under Section 143. An appeal lies under Section 415 of the BNSS, and revision or a petition under Section 528 of the BNSS and Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India may follow.
Compounding can occur at any of these stages, as confirmed in K.M. Ibrahim v. K.P. Mohammed (2010). Under the general rule now in Section 359(8) of the BNSS, corresponding to Section 320(8) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, compounding has the effect of an acquittal. The costs are a condition of compounding, not part of any sentence, so payment of costs does not imply any finding of guilt.
Can a costs order be challenged? Yes. If the court imposes costs in a manner inconsistent with the guidelines, for example by imposing costs at the first or second hearing, by calculating them on a wrong base, or by refusing reduction without considering relevant circumstances or recording reasons, the accused may challenge the order in revision before the Sessions Court or High Court, or by a petition under Section 528 of the BNSS. However, courts generally give considerable latitude to the compounding courtโs exercise of discretion.
Constitutional principles support the costs regime. Article 21 of the Constitution includes the right to a speedy trial, and the graded costs encourage early settlement, reducing delays for all litigants. Article 14 requires consistent treatment, which uniform guidelines promote, while the power to reduce costs with reasons prevents arbitrariness. Article 39A promotes legal aid, and the costs paid to Legal Services Authorities fund legal aid for those who cannot afford it. Article 142 provided the Supreme Courtโs authority to lay down the guidelines, and Article 141 makes them binding.
Let me also address further recourse. If a complainant deliberately delays settlement to increase the accusedโs costs, the accused may point this out when seeking reduction. If a complainant uses threats to extract more than what is owed, extortion under Section 308 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) or criminal intimidation under Section 351 may be considered. If the original cheque was misused, complaints for cheating under Section 318, forgery under Section 336 and using a forged document under Section 340 may be considered. A person falsely prosecuted may consider defamation under Section 356.
My practical advice for accused persons is this. If you intend to settle, do it at the first or second hearing, when no compounding costs apply. If you settle later, budget for ten, fifteen or twenty percent of the cheque amount in costs depending on the stage, in addition to what you pay the complainant. If you have good reasons, such as delay caused by the complainant or genuine hardship, file a written application for reduction with supporting material. For complainants, remember that encouraging an early settlement benefits you too, by reducing delay and expense.
To conclude, compounding costs imposed by the court at later stages are firmly grounded in the Supreme Courtโs guidelines in Damodar S. Prabhu, laid down under Article 142 and binding under Article 141. Costs rise from nil at the first or second hearing to ten, fifteen and twenty percent of the cheque amount at later stages, payable to the Legal Services Authority, with discretion to reduce them for recorded reasons. Understanding compounding costs imposed by the court helps accused persons settle at the right time and argue effectively for reduction where justified.
