Can one party refus...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Can one party refuse to compound even if the other party wants to settle?

2 Posts
2 Users
0 Reactions
5 Views
Posts: 1
Topic starter
(@Shreya mittal)
Joined: 1 week ago
[#9572]

My cheque bounce case has been going on for a while, and both sides are now willing to compromise over the past year. Given this situation, I want to know: Can one party refuse to compound even if the other party wants to settle?


1 Reply
Posts: 4615
(@advocate-mudit-pratap)
Member
Joined: 6 months ago

Settlement takes two willing parties. In cheque bounce cases, it is common for one side to want to settle while the other does not. An accused may be ready to pay, but the complainant, angry at years of delay, insists on seeing the accused convicted. Or a complainant may offer to settle, but the accused, convinced of their innocence, wants a full acquittal on merits. Both sides ask the same question: can the other party simply refuse? Let me explain clearly. Either party can refuse to compound a cheque bounce case, because compounding under Section 147 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 is consensual. But the law does not allow a complainant who has been fully compensated to block closure indefinitely, and the Supreme Court has created important exceptions for such situations.

Let me begin with the basic principle. Section 147 provides that, notwithstanding anything in the Code of Criminal Procedure, every offence punishable under the Act shall be compoundable. Compounding means a settlement between the complainant and the accused, by which the complainant gives up the prosecution. In JIK Industries Ltd. v. Amarlal V. Jumani (2012), the Supreme Court held that compounding essentially requires the consent of the complainant, because it is the complainant who is the person aggrieved and who must agree to give up the prosecution. The Court also held that a scheme of arrangement approved under company law, binding creditors generally, does not amount to compounding without the complainantโ€™s individual consent.

So, as a starting point, the complainant cannot be forced to compound. A complainant who believes that the accused acted dishonestly, or who wants the courtโ€™s verdict, is entitled to pursue the prosecution to its conclusion. The court cannot compel the complainant to accept a settlement amount they do not agree to, and it cannot treat the case as compounded merely because the accused wishes to settle.

Equally, the accused cannot be forced to compound. An accused who believes they are innocent, for example because the cheque was a security cheque misused before any liability arose, or because the debt was repaid, may refuse a settlement offer and insist on a trial. Compounding would involve paying the complainant, which an innocent accused may reasonably refuse. The accused has a constitutional right to defend themselves under Article 21, and the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139, as explained in Rangappa v. Sri Mohan (2010), can be rebutted on a preponderance of probabilities, as held in Basalingappa v. Mudibasappa (2019).

What about Lok Adalats and mediation? These forums are also consensual. Under Section 20 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, a case can be referred to a Lok Adalat if the parties agree or if the court is satisfied that there are chances of settlement, but the Lok Adalat can make an award only on the basis of a compromise or settlement between the parties. If either party does not agree, the case returns to the court for adjudication. Court-annexed mediation likewise depends on the voluntary agreement of both sides.

Now let me explain the important exception for a complainant who has been fully compensated. The Supreme Court has recognised that the object of Section 138 is primarily compensatory. In Damodar S. Prabhu v. Sayed Babalal H. (2010), the Court described cheque dishonour as primarily a civil wrong that has been criminalised. In Meters and Instruments Pvt. Ltd. v. Kanchan Mehta (2017), the Court held that where the accused pays the cheque amount with reasonable interest and costs, the court may, in the interests of justice, close the proceedings and discharge the accused, even without the complainantโ€™s consent, because the compensatory purpose has been served and continuing the prosecution would serve no useful purpose.

The Supreme Court went further in Raj Reddy Kallem v. State of Haryana (2024). There, the accused had paid the complainant substantial amounts, but the complainant refused to compound. The Supreme Court, exercising its power under Article 142 of the Constitution to do complete justice, set aside the conviction and closed the proceedings, observing that the complainant had been compensated and that insisting on punishment in such circumstances would not serve the purpose of the law. This decision shows that a complainantโ€™s refusal is not an absolute veto where the accused has fully compensated them.

Because the outcome of a refusal depends on whether the accused has fully compensated the complainant and on how the matter is presented to the court, professional advice is valuable. The settlement-dispute counsel at Aapka Legal Advice can help you decide how to respond when the other side refuses to settle. For representation before the trial court, appellate court or High Court, the Top Cheque Bounce Lawyers in India | Aapka Legal Advice handle contested settlement situations.

Let me now explain what an accused should do if the complainant refuses to settle. First, if the accused can pay, they should deposit the cheque amount with reasonable interest in court, along with an application explaining the payment and the complainantโ€™s refusal, and seek closure following Kanchan Mehta. Depositing in court, rather than paying directly, creates an undisputed record. Second, the accused should be prepared to pay costs as the court may direct under Damodar S. Prabhu. Third, if the trial court refuses closure, the accused may raise the issue in revision before the High Court, or under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), or ultimately before the Supreme Court under Article 136 and Article 142.

What counts as full compensation? Following Kanchan Mehta, the court looks at the cheque amount, reasonable interest and costs. In R. Vijayan v. Baby (2012), the Supreme Court indicated that simple interest at nine percent per annum on the cheque amount is a reasonable measure of the complainantโ€™s loss, and many courts use this benchmark. Litigation costs may also be added. An accused who offers only the bare cheque amount after many years of delay may not be treated as having fully compensated the complainant.

What can a complainant do if the accused refuses to settle? The complainant cannot compel the accused to compound, but the complainant has several tools. The complainant may seek interim compensation under Section 143A, which the Supreme Court in Rakesh Ranjan Shrivastava v. State of Jharkhand (2024) held is discretionary and depends on a prima facie assessment of the merits. The complainant may press for an early trial and, on conviction, seek compensation up to twice the cheque amount under Section 138 and Section 395 of the BNSS. The complainant may also pursue a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 in parallel. An accused who refuses a reasonable settlement and is later convicted may face a heavier sentence.

What about a complainant who refuses a reduced settlement? A complainant is entitled to refuse to accept less than the full amount. The Kanchan Mehta and Raj Reddy Kallem principles apply where the complainant has been fully compensated, not where the accused offers a lesser sum. So an accused who cannot pay in full must either persuade the complainant to accept less, which under Section 63 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 the complainant may lawfully do, or continue to defend the case.

What happens when there are multiple complainants or multiple accused? Each complainant must consent to compound the offence in respect of their own cheque. Where a company and its directors are accused under Section 141, a settlement with the company usually ends the case against all accused, but if some accused refuse to join the settlement, the order should specify with whom the offence is compounded. Under the general rule now in Section 359(8) of the BNSS, corresponding to Section 320(8) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, composition has the effect of an acquittal of the accused with whom the offence has been compounded.

Let me now explain the wider procedure. The cheque must be presented within three months of its date under clause (a) of the proviso to Section 138. The payee must send a written notice within thirty days of receiving information of dishonour under clause (b), and the drawer has fifteen days to pay under clause (c). If the drawer pays within this window, no offence is committed and the question of compounding does not arise. If not, the complaint must be filed within one month under Section 142(1)(b), before the Magistrate where the payeeโ€™s bank branch is situated, under Section 142(2). Under Section 223 of the BNSS, the accused is heard before cognizance, and bail is a right under Section 478. The trial is summary under Section 143.

On conviction, the sentence may include imprisonment of up to two years, a fine of up to twice the cheque amount, or both. An appeal lies under Section 415 of the BNSS, with a deposit under Section 148 ordinarily required, as held in Surinder Singh Deswal v. Virender Gandhi (2019). Compounding remains possible at every stage, as confirmed in K.M. Ibrahim v. K.P. Mohammed (2010), but only with consent, subject to the Kanchan Mehta and Raj Reddy Kallem exceptions.

Constitutional principles balance the partiesโ€™ rights. Article 21 of the Constitution protects the accusedโ€™s personal liberty and right to defend themselves, which is why an accused cannot be forced to compound. It also supports the Supreme Courtโ€™s approach that a fully compensated complainant should not be able to insist on punishment, since unnecessary criminal consequences would be disproportionate. Article 14 requires fair treatment of both sides. Article 142 empowers the Supreme Court to do complete justice, as in Raj Reddy Kallem. Article 39A promotes access to justice through mediation and Lok Adalats.

Let me also address further recourse. If a complainant uses the refusal to compound as leverage to extract amounts far beyond what is owed, with threats, the accused may consider extortion under Section 308 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) or criminal intimidation under Section 351. If the complainant makes false public allegations, defamation under Section 356 may be considered. If the original cheque was misused, complaints for cheating under Section 318, forgery under Section 336 and using a forged document under Section 340 may be considered.

My practical advice for accused persons is this. If the complainant refuses to settle and you can pay, deposit the cheque amount with reasonable interest in court and seek closure under Kanchan Mehta. If you cannot pay in full, try mediation and explain your position honestly. If you are innocent, you are entitled to refuse a settlement and contest the case. For complainants, you may refuse an inadequate offer, but understand that once you have been fully compensated, courts will not allow you to keep the prosecution alive merely to punish.

To conclude, either party can refuse to compound a cheque bounce case, because compounding under Section 147 is consensual, as JIK Industries held. An accused cannot be forced to settle, and a complainant cannot be forced to accept less. But where the accused has fully compensated the complainant, Kanchan Mehta and Raj Reddy Kallem allow courts to close the case despite the complainantโ€™s refusal. Understanding when a party can refuse to compound a cheque bounce case helps both sides negotiate realistically and use the lawโ€™s safeguards wisely.


Reply
Share: