My cheque bounce complaint was filed some months back, and I want to understand what happens at each stage of the trial from here. Given this situation, I want to know: Can the court refuse to issue summons even after a complaint is filed?
Many complainants assume that filing a cheque bounce complaint automatically leads to a summons against the accused. After all, they have the bounced cheque, the bankโs memo and a copy of the notice. So it comes as a shock when the Magistrate dismisses the complaint without even summoning the accused. Accused persons, on the other hand, often do not realise that a defective complaint can be stopped at the threshold. Let me explain clearly. A court can refuse to issue summons in a cheque bounce case, and dismiss the complaint, if it finds no sufficient ground for proceeding, under Section 226 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), which corresponds to Section 203 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This happens most often where the statutory requirements of Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 have not been met.
Let me begin with the legal framework. When a complaint is filed, the Magistrate examines the complainant under Section 223 of the BNSS, usually on affidavit as permitted by Section 145(1) of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The proviso to Section 223(1) requires that the accused be given an opportunity of being heard before cognizance is taken. Where the accused resides outside the Magistrateโs jurisdiction, the Magistrate conducts an inquiry under Section 225 of the BNSS, corresponding to Section 202 of the old Code. Then, under Section 226 of the BNSS, if after considering the statements of the complainant and witnesses and the result of any inquiry, the Magistrate is of the opinion that there is no sufficient ground for proceeding, the Magistrate shall dismiss the complaint, briefly recording the reasons. If there is sufficient ground, the Magistrate issues process under Section 227.
The Supreme Court has emphasised that summoning is not a mechanical step. In Pepsi Foods Ltd. v. Special Judicial Magistrate (1998), it held that summoning an accused in a criminal case is a serious matter, that criminal law cannot be set in motion as a matter of course, and that the Magistrate must apply their mind to the facts and the law before issuing summons. So the Magistrate has both the power and the duty to refuse summons where the complaint does not disclose an offence.
Let me now explain the common grounds on which courts refuse to issue summons in cheque cases. The first is limitation. Under Section 142(1)(b), the complaint must be filed within one month of the date on which the cause of action arises, which is after the expiry of fifteen days from receipt of the notice. If the complaint is filed late and no application for condonation of delay is made, or the delay is not explained, the Magistrate may refuse to take cognizance. The proviso to Section 142(1)(b) allows condonation for sufficient cause, so complainants who are late should always file a condonation application with reasons.
The second ground is a defective or missing notice. Clause (b) of the proviso to Section 138 requires the payee to make a demand for payment by a written notice within thirty days of receiving information of dishonour. If no notice was sent, or it was sent beyond thirty days, or it did not demand the cheque amount, the offence is not made out. In K.R. Indira v. Dr. G. Adinarayana (2003) and Suman Sethi v. Ajay K. Churiwal (2000), the Supreme Court considered the requirements of the notice, holding that the notice must demand the cheque amount, though inclusion of other amounts such as interest or costs, if severable, does not invalidate it.
The third ground is presentation outside the validity period. Clause (a) of the proviso to Section 138 requires the cheque to be presented within six months from the date on which it is drawn or within its validity period, whichever is earlier, which under Reserve Bank of India directions is three months. A cheque presented after expiry of its validity does not attract Section 138.
The fourth ground is the reason for dishonour. Section 138 applies where the cheque is returned because the amount standing to the credit of the account is insufficient or exceeds the arrangement. In NEPC Micon Ltd. v. Magma Leasing Ltd. (1999), the Supreme Court held that โaccount closedโ is covered, and in Modi Cements Ltd. v. Kuchil Kumar Nandi (1998) and Laxmi Dyechem v. State of Gujarat (2012), it held that โpayment stoppedโ and โsignature mismatchโ may also attract the section. But a cheque returned purely for a technical reason attributable to the bank, unrelated to the drawerโs account, may not. The return memo must be examined.
The fifth ground is that the complainant is not the payee or holder in due course. Under Section 142(1)(a), only the payee or holder in due course can file the complaint. A complaint filed by someone else, without proper authority, may be dismissed. Where the complainant is a company, the complaint must be filed through a duly authorised person, as discussed in A.C. Narayanan v. State of Maharashtra (2014).
Because a complaint dismissed at the threshold can sometimes be difficult to revive, both complainants and accused persons benefit from careful scrutiny at this stage. The complaint-scrutiny team at Aapka Legal Advice can review a complaint for defects before it is filed or before the pre-cognizance hearing. For representation before the Magistrate or in revision, the Top Cheque Bounce Lawyers in India | Aapka Legal Advice handle both filing and threshold challenges.
The sixth ground concerns vicarious liability. Where the complaint names directors or partners under Section 141, it must contain specific averments that each of them was in charge of and responsible to the company for the conduct of its business at the relevant time, as held in S.M.S. Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. Neeta Bhalla (2005), National Small Industries Corporation Ltd. v. Harmeet Singh Paintal (2010) and Ashok Shewakramani v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2023). The company itself must be arraigned, as held in Aneeta Hada v. Godfather Travels and Tours (2012). The Magistrate may refuse to summon directors against whom there are no proper averments, even while summoning the company.
The seventh ground is territorial jurisdiction. Under Section 142(2), the complaint must be filed where the payeeโs bank branch is located. If it is filed in the wrong court, the Magistrate should return it for presentation before the proper court rather than dismiss it on merits. The 2015 amendment and the decision in Bridgestone India Pvt. Ltd. v. Inderpal Singh (2016) clarified this jurisdiction rule.
The eighth ground relates to the drawerโs account. In Jugesh Sehgal v. Shamsher Singh Gogi (2009), the Supreme Court held that Section 138 applies only to a cheque drawn on an account maintained by the accused. If the complaint names a person who did not draw the cheque and does not maintain the account, and Section 141 does not apply, the Magistrate may refuse to summon that person.
What happens at the pre-cognizance hearing? The proviso to Section 223(1) gives the accused an opportunity to be heard before cognizance. The accused can point out the defects I have described. The Magistrate should consider these submissions. The hearing is not a mini-trial; disputed factual defences, such as whether the cheque was a security cheque, are ordinarily left for trial because of the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139, as explained in Rangappa v. Sri Mohan (2010).
What remedies does the complainant have if summons is refused? The complainant may file a revision before the Sessions Court or High Court against the order dismissing the complaint. The complainant may also, in limited circumstances, file a fresh complaint. In Pramatha Nath Talukdar v. Saroj Ranjan Sarkar (1962) and Poonam Chand Jain v. Fazru (2010), the Supreme Court held that a second complaint on the same facts after dismissal under the provision now in Section 226 is maintainable only in exceptional circumstances, such as where the earlier order was passed on an incomplete record, a manifest error, or new facts that could not have been produced earlier with reasonable diligence. A complainant whose complaint was dismissed for limitation will usually be unable to file a fresh complaint on the same cheque.
What if the defect is curable? Sometimes the defect is minor, such as a missing document or an incomplete affidavit. A careful Magistrate may allow the complainant to cure the defect rather than dismissing the complaint. Complainants should respond promptly to any queries from the court. Where directors are named without proper averments, courts have sometimes permitted amendment of the complaint before cognizance, though the law on amendment of complaints is limited and depends on the nature of the defect.
What remedies does the accused have if summons is issued despite defects? Because a Magistrate cannot recall or review an order issuing process, as held in Adalat Prasad v. Rooplal Jindal (2004) and reaffirmed in In Re: Expeditious Trial of Cases under Section 138 of N.I. Act, 1881 (2021), the accusedโs remedy is a revision or a petition under Section 528 of the BNSS or Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India before the High Court for quashing.
Let me now explain the wider procedure. The cheque must be presented within three months of its date. The payee must send a written notice within thirty days of receiving information of dishonour, and the drawer has fifteen days to pay. If the drawer pays within that time, no offence arises. If not, the complaint must be filed within one month. If summons is issued, the accused appears, obtains bail under Section 478 of the BNSS, pleads, and the trial proceeds under the summary procedure of Section 143. The offence is compoundable under Section 147, with costs under Damodar S. Prabhu v. Sayed Babalal H. (2010).
Constitutional principles support the power to refuse summons. Article 21 of the Constitution protects personal liberty and dignity, and summoning a person on a defective complaint is an unjustified intrusion. The pre-cognizance hearing under the BNSS strengthens this protection. Article 14 requires that the power be exercised with reasons and not arbitrarily. Article 39A supports access to legal aid at this early stage.
Let me also address further recourse. An accused who faced a frivolous complaint may consider a civil suit for malicious prosecution and a complaint for defamation under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS). Where the cheque was misused, complaints for cheating under Section 318, forgery under Section 336, using a forged document under Section 340 and extortion under Section 308 may be considered. A complainant whose complaint fails on a technicality may still pursue civil recovery through a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, subject to limitation.
My practical advice for complainants is this. Before filing, check every statutory requirement: presentation within validity, notice within thirty days, proof of delivery, expiry of fifteen days, filing within one month, correct court and proper averments against directors. If you are late, file a condonation application. For accused persons, attend the pre-cognizance hearing and point out clear legal defects with documents. If summons is issued despite such defects, approach the High Court promptly.
To conclude, a court can refuse to issue summons in a cheque bounce case and dismiss the complaint under Section 226 of the BNSS where there is no sufficient ground, most often because of limitation, a defective notice, presentation outside validity, the wrong reason for dishonour, absence of proper averments against directors or other statutory defects. Understanding when a court can refuse to issue summons in a cheque bounce case helps complainants file correctly and accused persons protect themselves from defective prosecutions.
